Quick heads-up: This post contains affiliate links to gear sites like Amazon, Reverb, and our other partners. If you buy something through these links, I get a small piece of the pie to help keep this blog running, but it doesn't cost you a penny extra!
Most used gear buying guides make the process sound either terrifying (scammers everywhere, hidden damage, expensive regrets) or unrealistically simple. The truth sits in the middle. The risks are manageable, the savings are real, and a few consistent habits keep you out of trouble.
This is the practical guide for people who want to buy used gear intelligently without spending weeks researching every purchase.
Who This Guide Is For
- Players and producers who want to save real money on quality gear
- Anyone new to Reverb or other used marketplaces
- Buyers who have been burned before or are nervous about condition issues
Who This Is Not For
- Collectors hunting mint, investment-grade pieces
- People unwilling to ask questions or examine photos carefully
- Buyers looking for “too good to be true” deals on high-demand items
1. The Photographs Tell You More Than the Description
A seller who provides multiple clear photos from different angles is giving you more honest information than a long written description. Photos show the ding on the headstock, the replaced knob, the finish crack, or the clean frets that the text might gloss over.
Look at every photo carefully before you read the description. Then check whether the description matches what you see. If the listing only has one or two photos, ask for more. Legitimate sellers usually send them quickly. Resistance or delay is information.
2. Seller Ratings Are the First Filter
Sort by seller rating and completed sales before you sort by price. A seller with hundreds of positive transactions has a track record on description accuracy, packing, and problem resolution. A brand-new seller with a suspiciously low price is a higher-risk proposition.
On Reverb, high feedback count plus strong ratings is the practical starting filter. Once that filter is applied, then compare prices inside the safer pool.
Shop Used Gear on Reverb
Best for: Finding quality used instruments, amps, mics, and studio gear with buyer protection
The deepest dedicated music gear marketplace. Use seller ratings and clear photos as your first filters.
3. Ask Specific Questions Before You Buy
Message the seller with concrete questions:
- Do the pots crackle? Does the output jack cut out?
- Are the pickups and electronics original?
- When were the tubes last replaced (for amps)?
- Any known issues not fully visible in the photos?
Quick, specific, honest answers are a green flag. Vague replies, long delays, or defensiveness are yellow or red flags. Good sellers are used to these questions.
4. Understand What Condition Grades Actually Mean
- Mint — Essentially new, little to no visible wear
- Excellent — Light play wear, no structural issues
- Very Good — Obvious wear but fully functional
- Good — Significant wear, possible minor issues
- Fair / Poor — Problems that should be clearly disclosed
Some sellers grade optimistically. Always cross-check the grade against the photos and the written description. Trust your eyes more than the label.
5. Make Offers on Listings That Have Been Sitting
An item still listed after two or more weeks has not sold at the asking price. A reasonable offer (often 10–15% below ask on many items) is frequently accepted. Fresh listings priced at or below market value will usually sell quickly — lowballing those is mostly a waste of time.
Categories Where Used Is Usually the Smart Move
- Tube amplifiers — Broken-in tubes and aged components often sound better than brand-new units
- Acoustic guitars — Wood that has opened up over years
- Studio microphones from reputable brands (SM7B, many condensers, etc.) — Sound the same used, cost less
- Pedals from major makers (Boss, MXR, EHX, etc.) — Built tough; used is low risk
- Many electric guitars and basses — Especially when you can verify neck and electronics condition
Used Studio Microphones Shure SM7B
Best for: Getting professional vocal sound without paying full new price
A clean used SM7B or comparable dynamic performs the same as new and regularly appears at meaningful discounts.
Categories Where New Often Makes More Sense
- Audio interfaces (driver support and longevity concerns on older units)
- Cables (the savings rarely justify the risk of intermittent problems)
- Drum heads and strings (consumables — buy new)
- Items where the newest firmware or computer compatibility matters
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it safe to buy used gear on Reverb?
Yes when you stick to highly rated sellers, examine photos carefully, ask questions, and use the platform’s buyer protection. Most problems come from ignoring those basics.
What is the biggest red flag?
Very low price + new or low-feedback seller + limited photos + vague answers to questions.
Should I always make an offer?
Not on fresh, well-priced listings. Offers are most effective on items that have been listed for a while.
Are used tube amps and acoustic guitars really better?
Often yes in terms of feel and tone. Age and playing-in can improve certain instruments and amps. Condition still matters.
What should I do as soon as the gear arrives?
Inspect it carefully against the listing, test everything, and contact the seller/platform quickly if something is not as described.
Final Recommendation
Filter by strong seller ratings first. Study the photos. Ask specific questions. Understand the condition grade in context. Be willing to offer on older listings. Buy used confidently in categories where the risk is low and the savings are real, and buy new when reliability or compatibility is more important than the discount.
Used gear is one of the highest-leverage ways to get better instruments and studio tools without overspending. Done carefully, it is not risky — it is simply smart.
For more buying guidance, see:
- Used Music Gear Complete Buying Guide
- Used Gibson Guitars
- Home Studio Essentials
- Home Studio Build Guide Under $1,000
- Recommended Gear
Follow Phantom Power Gear on Pinterest for more gear tips and recommendations.
This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through one of our links we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.